This article examines why some supplements commonly given to dogs and cats can pose serious health risks, even when marketed as “natural” or safe. By unpacking how dosing, formulation, and species-specific differences are often overlooked, it challenges the assumption that supplements are inherently harmless—an issue especially relevant for pet owners navigating today’s crowded pet wellness market in Sacramento.

Understanding the Dangers of Supplements for Your Pets

Most of us who share our lives with pets have had this thought at least once: If it’s natural, it must be safe.

It’s an easy assumption to make—especially when shelves are packed with calming chews, joint formulas, and wellness powders promising happier, healthier dogs and cats. But as many Sacramento pet owners are starting to learn, supplements can be far more complicated—and risky—than they appear.

In a widely shared educational video, Dr. Andrew Jones, a longtime veterinarian known for his work in integrative pet health, breaks down an uncomfortable truth: some supplements marketed for pets—or borrowed from human medicine—can cause serious harm when used incorrectly.

His message isn’t meant to scare pet parents away from caring deeply for their animals. It’s meant to slow us down, sharpen our awareness, and help us make safer choices.

What follows is a closer look at why supplements can turn dangerous, which ingredients deserve extra caution, and how whole-food approaches can often offer a safer path forward.

In When Can Supplements Turn Dangerous for Dogs and Cats?, the discussion dives into critical insights about pet supplements, exploring important safety information that sparked deeper inquiries on our end.

When “Helpful” Turns Harmful

Walk into any pet store and you’ll see rows of products designed to solve common problems: anxiety, joint stiffness, digestion, even yellow spots on the lawn. The marketing is friendly and reassuring. Words like natural, gentle, and vet-approved appear everywhere.

The problem is that “natural” doesn’t automatically mean “harmless.”

Dr. Jones explains that many supplements are perfectly safe at the right dose, but trouble starts when ingredients are added in excessive amounts or combined without careful oversight.

Unlike prescription medications, supplements are not always regulated with the same level of scrutiny. That means dosing errors, poor formulations, and misleading claims can slip through the cracks.

For a small dog or cat, even a slight overdose can have outsized consequences.

The Ingredients That Raise Red Flags

Some of the most concerning supplements aren’t obscure or rare—they’re surprisingly common. Many appear in calming chews, joint formulas, or even everyday human vitamins that well-meaning owners sometimes share with pets.

Here are a few ingredients that deserve special attention.

L-Tryptophan and 5-HTP: Calming, but at a Cost

These compounds influence serotonin, a neurotransmitter involved in mood regulation. In carefully controlled amounts, they may support relaxation. But when levels climb too high, they can overstimulate the nervous system and trigger serotonin syndrome.

Symptoms may include vomiting, diarrhea, tremors, disorientation, lethargy, seizures, and collapse—especially when products contain unusually high doses.

Dr. Andrew Jones explains:

“Low doses can be helpful, but excessive amounts of tryptophan or 5-HTP can overstimulate the nervous system and cause real harm.”

The greatest risk comes from supplements that advertise being “extra-strength” or “more powerful” without clearly disclosing safe dosing limits.

Glucosamine and Manganese: When “More” Becomes the Problem

Glucosamine has a long track record of helping support joint health, and when used at appropriate doses, it is generally well tolerated by dogs and cats. Problems tend to arise only when products dramatically exceed recommended amounts or pair glucosamine with excessive levels of manganese.

At extremely high doses, pets may experience significant gastrointestinal upset, including vomiting, diarrhea, and abdominal discomfort.

In rare cases, prolonged or severe digestive stress can place secondary strain on the liver—especially in older animals or those with pre-existing health conditions.

The issue isn’t glucosamine itself. It’s the growing trend of supplements that boast being ten times stronger than competitors, assuming higher doses automatically mean better results.

Methionine: The “Grass Saver” Trade-Off

Products marketed to reduce yellow lawn spots often rely on methionine, an amino acid that acidifies urine. While this may protect grass, excessive intake can disrupt normal metabolism.

High doses of methionine have been associated with tremors, weakness, seizures, and neurological symptoms that may persist for up to 48 hours. In this case, the cosmetic benefit simply doesn’t justify the health risk.

Vitamin D: Essential—but Already Accounted For

Vitamin D plays an important role in calcium regulation and overall health. The key issue is not vitamin D itself, but unnecessary supplementation.

Most commercial dog and cat foods already contain balanced, sufficient amounts of vitamin D. Adding extra—especially through human supplements—can push levels into a toxic range.

Excess vitamin D can raise calcium levels in the blood, leading to kidney damage, heart abnormalities, and long-term organ failure. This is one of the most commonly reported supplement-related toxicities seen in veterinary practice.

In short: vitamin D is essential, but additional supplementation in pets is rarely needed and often dangerous.

Iron: A Heavy Mineral with Little Margin for Error

Iron deficiency is common in humans, which makes iron supplements feel familiar and harmless. For pets, the situation is very different.

Excess iron can severely irritate the gastrointestinal tract and, in higher amounts, cause liver failure, shock, and life-threatening systemic damage. True iron deficiency in pets is uncommon and should always be evaluated by a veterinarian before any supplementation is considered.

When iron is needed, small amounts from whole-food sources—such as red meat—are far safer than concentrated supplements.

Alpha Lipoic Acid: A Serious Risk for Cats

Alpha lipoic acid is one supplement that deserves special caution, particularly when it comes to cats. Cats metabolize this compound very differently than dogs, making them far more vulnerable to its effects.

Even small amounts can interfere with normal blood sugar regulation, triggering weakness, tremors, loss of coordination, or seizures.

Because the safety margin is so narrow, veterinary professionals strongly advise keeping alpha lipoic acid completely out of reach of cats and avoiding its use in pets unless specifically directed by a veterinarian.ylitol: A Known Emergency for Dogs—and Still Best Avoided for Cats

Xylitol is a sugar substitute commonly found in chewable vitamins, flavored supplements, and “sugar-free” products. In dogs, its effects are severe and well documented.

Xylitol causes a rapid release of insulin, leading to a sudden and dangerous drop in blood sugar. This can result in weakness, seizures, coma, liver failure, and death within hours.

While xylitol toxicity is most clearly established in dogs, veterinary professionals recommend avoiding it entirely for cats as well. If a supplement is flavored or chewable, reading the ingredient list is critical—xylitol should always be a deal-breaker.

Why Whole Foods Are Often the Safer Choice

One of the most reassuring points Dr. Jones emphasizes is that many nutrients pets need can come from real food rather than synthetic pills.

Whole foods deliver nutrients in balanced forms that the body is designed to process. Fish oil can provide omega-3 fatty acids, lean meats offer bioavailable iron and protein, and vegetables supply natural vitamins without the risk of concentrated overdose.

This approach doesn’t eliminate the need for supplements entirely—but it significantly lowers the risk of accidental toxicity.

Learning to Read Labels Like a Vet

Supplement labels can feel overwhelming, especially when ingredient names sound technical or unfamiliar. A few habits can dramatically reduce risk:

• Be cautious of products advertising extremely high doses

• Avoid flavored supplements unless you’ve checked carefully for xylitol

• Be skeptical of human supplements repurposed for pets

• Choose brands that clearly list exact ingredient amounts

• Consult your veterinarian before introducing anything new

A short conversation with a professional can prevent months—or years—of health complications.

The Emotional Side of Pet Health Decisions

Pets aren’t just animals we care for; they’re family. They share our homes, routines, and quiet moments. When they’re unwell, the stress ripples through the household.

It’s easy to reach for supplements out of love, hoping to ease anxiety, stiffness, or aging-related changes. But true care sometimes means resisting quick fixes and choosing the slower, safer path of informed decision-making.

Knowledge as an Act of Love

The supplement industry isn’t going away, and not all supplements are dangerous. Many can be helpful when used responsibly. The difference lies in understanding the risks, respecting dosage limits, and recognizing that pets are not small humans.

By learning which ingredients to avoid, favoring whole-food solutions, and partnering with trusted veterinarians, pet owners can make choices that truly support long-term well-being.

As Dr. Jones reminds us, awareness isn’t about fear—it’s about empowerment. And for the animals who depend on us completely, informed care may be one of the greatest gifts we can give.

Discover additional pet wellness resources inside Healthy Pets, or explore the full range of local lifestyle features on Sacramento Living Well.

---
Prepared by the Sacramento Living Well Editorial Team — presented by DSA Digital Media, your trusted voice for wellness and community stories across Sacramento.